Payment Procedures
Payment Procedures vary from company to company and could include payment by mail, phone, online, installments, EFT (Electronic Funds Transfer) and/or finance agreements. Please see the Company Contact Information section for specific payment procedures by company. Also, for your convenience, payments can be made at Fair & Yeager Insurance Agency, 8:30 am to 5:00 pm, Monday to Friday.
Please note, if you are paying by installments, most all insurance companies charge an installment fee. If your payment is late, late fees typically will apply. Also, be advised that a notice of cancellation for non-payment of premium, or being cancelled for non-pay, is on an individual basis and does require a call in to the agency and/or insurance company.
Company Contact Information
AMGRO/Premium Financing Specialists (Finance Company) - Payments may be made online 24/7 at www.premiumfinance.com EFT is available. Payments can be mailed to: Premium Financing Specialists, Inc. P.O. Box 15089 Worcester, MA 01615-0089 Ph 1-800-922-8195
Commerce Insurance - Payments can also be made online 24/7 at www.commercecares.com or payments can be made by phone with a check, a fee of $2.95 will be charged, at 1-800-922-8276 between the hours of 8:00 am and 6:00 pm M - F. EFT is available. Payments can be mailed to: 11 Gore Road, Webster, MA 01570.
CNA - Payments can be made by phone with a check at no charge using the phone number 1-877-276-7507. This service is available 8am to 8pm M - F. EFT is available. Payments can be mailed to: CNA P.O. Box 382033 Pittsburgh, PA 15250-8033
Hanover Insurance - Payments can be made by phone with a check/Debit Card using the phone number 1-800-573-1187. Payments may be made online using the website www.myhanoverpolicy.com EFT is available. Payments can be mailed to: PO Box 580045 Charlotte, NC 28258
MA Fair Plan - Payments can be made online with a check using the website www.mpiua.com. Please note when paying online you must provide an invoice #, which can be found on your invoice. Payments can be mailed to: PO Box 981030 Boston, MA 02298-1030, If a payment has to be mailed overnight mail to: Two Center Plaza Boston, MA 02108.
Merchants - Payments can be made by phone with a check using the phone number
Merrimack - 1-800-225-0770, no alternate payment options are available. Payments may be made by mail, or dropped off at Fair & Yeager Insurance Agency. EFT is available. Payments can be mailed to: 95 Old River Road Andover, MA 01810.
Preferred Mutual - Payments can be made by phone with a check at no charge using the phone number 1-800-333-7642 during the hours of 8:00am to 5:00pm M -F. The following options are available 24/7. By phone 1-888-511-2455 and www.pminsco.com using Visa, Mastercard, Debit Card or Echeck. Payments can be mailed to: PO Box 888 Norwich, NY 13815-0888.
Safety Insurance - Payments can be made online at www.safetyinsurance.com or by phone 1-800-951-2100 x 3200, between the hours of 8:15 am - 5:00 pm M-F. Credit Cards are accepted, Visa & MasterCard and NYCE, Pulse, Star, and Accel Exchange network debit cards. EFT is available. Payments can be mailed (with payment stub) to: P.O. Box 371312, Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7312; (without payment stub) PO Box 55089 Boston, MA 02205-5089 (please do not forget to put your policy # on the check)
Travelers - Payments can be made by phone with a check at no charge using the phone number 1-800-252-2268. This service is available 24/7. Payments can also be made online at www.travelersepay.com. EFT is available. Payments can be mailed to: Travelers P.O. 660317 Dallas, TX 75266-0317
Questions
If you have any questions or would like to contact us regarding billing, click here, or call us at 508-653-3131.






